How Companies Can Blend AI and Human Expertise for Superior Customer Service
Extracts from a conversation with VP of CARE at VistaPrint
In the modern digital landscape, the customer experience is undergoing a significant transformation, spurred by advancements in Artificial Intelligence (AI) and consumers’ evolving expectations. As technology continues to break boundaries and redefine possibilities, businesses find themselves at an exciting yet daunting crossroads.
On one side lies the promise of AI, with its unmatched efficiency, data analysis prowess, and innovation potential. On the other, the age-old value of human connection, insight, and genuine interaction stands unwavering. The challenge? Seamlessly integrating these two seemingly divergent elements into a harmonized service experience that resonates with today’s digital-native audience.
This article, an extract from a recent interview where Christian Lunoe spoke with Paul Harraghy, VP of CARE at VistaPrint, explores the intricate balance between AI’s capabilities and the irreplaceable human touch in customer service. It examines how businesses, rather than replacing the warmth of human interaction, harness AI to augment, support, and elevate it.
Harnessing AI: Augmenting Human Expertise for Precision in Customer Service
Many businesses are acclimated to tools that require manual input — you direct the system towards what you want it to monitor. However, the transformative power of AI offers the ability to identify emerging trends and unexpected spikes in data automatically. It’s a shift from a reactive to a proactive model. While expressing concern about AI replacing human roles is valid, seeing the bigger picture is crucial. Instead of making tasks redundant, AI serves to optimize resources.
Quality assurance teams, for instance, can benefit immensely from AI. With automated scoring, AI can scan 100% of interactions, providing an instant overview of performance metrics. While the nuances of specific conversations might elude even the most advanced AI, it offers a preliminary layer of analysis. If AI picks up that a team isn’t performing optimally, it gives managers a starting point to further investigate and provide coaching.
AI isn’t about eradicating human roles but enabling them to be more precise. With AI handling bulk analysis, teams can concentrate on the intricate details of the human elements of interactions. The synthesis of human expertise and AI capabilities promises a future where tasks are streamlined, and professionals can focus on what truly matters — refining the quality of their service.
Similarly, the actual value of data isn’t merely in its acquisition but in its application, especially regarding customer interaction dynamics. A uniform quality scorecard across an organization enables a more holistic performance comparison. However, consistency in scoring metrics doesn’t imply uniformity in interpretation. Variances often exist in how different team members perceive the quality of a conversation. Recognizing this divergence is essential because it opens up pathways for alignment, ensuring that all stakeholders understand what constitutes an excellent customer interaction.
Augmentation tools, when used effectively, can pinpoint specific areas of focus. For instance, how refunds or replacements are handled in customer service can make or break customer trust. A company’s commitment to righting wrongs is commendable, yet striking a balance is crucial. Being too generous might seem like a win in the short term, but it could lead to substantial financial repercussions. On the other hand, being too frugal might deteriorate the customer experience.
With advanced tools, businesses can set parameters to analyze interactions. Teams can balance customer satisfaction and financial prudence by assessing whether credits were issued correctly or excessively. Such insights empower businesses to make more informed decisions, ensuring their actions resonate with the brand’s ethos without compromising its bottom line. It’s about navigating the gray areas in customer service with precision and clarity, fostering a culture where customer delight and organizational sustainability coexist.
Turning Raw Data into Actionable Insights: The Power of Deep Analysis
Returning to data, data in itself holds little value; its true power emerges when leveraged strategically. A simple hypothesis can be a starting point. By diving deep into the data, organizations can uncover actionable insights. It isn’t just about identifying overarching trends but also about breaking down data layer by layer—from the overall strategy to individual teams, down to single agents—to pinpoint areas that need attention.
Such meticulous analysis can prove invaluable. Analyzing areas of compliance with established policies and then measuring results against third-party data points, like the Net Promoter Score (NPS), it becomes clear whether efforts to tighten policies might inadvertently affect customer satisfaction.
However, focusing solely on one analytical tool might not paint the complete picture. A robust analytics team with various tools and models can extract many insights from different communication channels. This multi-pronged approach ensures that gaps in the data are minimized. This comprehensive insight is indispensable for substantial growth.
Level AI is a game-changer in this regard, not as a replacement but as a complementary tool that augments existing solutions. For instance, while efficient handling time in contact centers is paramount, it’s equally important to ensure that customers don’t experience unnecessary delays. Achieving this balance requires optimizing conversations, refining tools for specialists, addressing policy or product challenges, and providing adequate training.
Screen recording, an underutilized tool, offers invaluable insights. Recording a portion of interactions can unveil how specialists handle exchanges. When a customer is put on hold, what transpires behind the scenes? Traditional CRM clickstream data might offer clues, but screen recordings provide an unfiltered view. It becomes evident if specialists struggle with specific tools, adding unnecessary time to interactions. Identifying such pain points can pave the way for streamlined processes, ensuring that every minute of interaction delivers value.
Automated insights, another Level AI feature, allow for focused analysis. By categorizing specific interactions, one can discern trends, pull relevant screen recordings, and detect keywords that might hint at underlying challenges. Such insights empower quality teams, including those at VistaPrint, to enhance the customer experience further.
AI in Quality Assurance: Analyzing the Hidden Layers of Conversations
The pull of AI isn’t merely in its capacity for instantaneous transformation but in its ability to offer an additional layer of insight. Through a myriad of metrics, such as quality assurance scorecards, tagging data, and screen recordings, AI allows organizations to extract deeper meaning from ongoing conversations. But the path to integrating AI isn’t always seamless.
Venturing into AI is less about believing in its omnipotent abilities and more about recognizing the need for enhanced quality solutions. What sets specific solutions apart is their capability to offer automated insights, dynamism, and growth potential. Moreover, AI can supplement the skills of various teams, be it the quality team, team leads, or even customer feedback teams.
However, adopting AI isn’t without its challenges. The transition from traditional practices to AI-driven ones might be met with resistance, significantly when it disrupts established routines. For instance, replacing manual scoring and Excel sheets with automated solutions can be jarring for some. One common pitfall is the distrust that can emerge when specialists perceive automated scoring to be inaccurate. It’s vital to assess whether the AI-generated data is directionally accurate on an aggregate level rather than getting bogged down by occasional inaccuracies.
A relatable scenario for many involved in contact centers might be the variability in manual evaluations. Given the same interaction, different supervisors might arrive at diverse scores. Thus, some level of variability is inherent, whether manual or automated.
A striking endeavor in this AI integration journey is the automation of wrap-up codes. Traditionally, specialists would manually select the nature of each interaction at its conclusion. However, this method was fraught with inaccuracies, often due to the limitations of single-option selections or even the order of options listed. Automating this process, while not flawless, has proven more accurate than its manual counterpart.
Yet, every innovation has its share of critics. When anomalies arise, they tend to overshadow the majority of accurate instances. Keeping a macro perspective is crucial, understanding that no tool offers perfection at inception. Educating teams about the rationale behind AI adoption and emphasizing the long-term benefits over temporary hiccups ensures smoother implementation. One undeniable advantage? Liberating specialists from the minutiae, allowing AI to handle tasks like categorization, and letting them focus on what truly matters: the conversation.
Change Management in AI Adoption: Why and How Matters
Navigating the terrain of AI integration involves much more than merely deploying technology. It beckons organizations to master the art of change management. This is a dance of introducing the new, redefining processes and restructuring teams. A common challenge is ensuring everyone understands and embraces the change, from frontline agents to management.
At the heart of successful change management lies storytelling. Narrating the ‘why’ behind the integration is as vital as elucidating the ‘what.’ Without this anchor, the drive can seem aimless and prompt resistance. The importance of ‘why’ cannot be understated; it drives belief, fosters trust, and cultivates a sense of purpose. It answers the crucial question: what value does this change bring?
However, even with compelling storytelling, there will be gaps in adaptation and a variance in the results. While some teams may thrive with new tools, showcasing improved metrics like Net Promoter Score (NPS) or First Call Resolution, others might lag. The differential often hinges on the degree of engagement and understanding of the change’s benefits.
Key to the process is realizing that change isn’t just about leadership mandates. Maintaining open channels is imperative, where teams can influence and shape the course. Top-down decisions, especially those far removed from the ground reality, might not always align with current needs. Engaging those directly interacting with the tools, such as team leads and coaches, can offer invaluable insights, refining the change process.
Another layer to the journey is understanding that roles and perspectives evolve. Someone pivotal during the program’s launch might not be as engaged during its later stages. To ensure continued alignment, it’s crucial to reassess, recalibrate, and re-narrate the ‘why.’
The introduction of AI is not about setting up surveillance. It’s about optimization. The aim isn’t to audit but to ascertain areas of improvement, aiding in making the job of specialists more efficient and enhancing customer experiences. When this intent is clear, AI integration becomes a tool for growth, not a mechanism of oversight.
Management’s Role: Setting the Right Expectations
With these factors at play, it’s apparent that change management is pivotal in adopting AI in the contact center landscape. However, setting the right expectations upfront is essential when integrating these systems. For instance, clarifying that AI’s purpose isn’t to replace jobs but to improve customer interactions can alleviate staff apprehensions. This requires a robust feedback mechanism with stakeholders to ensure continued buy-in and understanding of the system’s benefits.
Tracking tools like Level AI offer a glimpse into team engagement, allowing supervisors to monitor evaluations and coaching sessions. These insights, visualized through dashboards, provide a comprehensive view of the call drivers, quality of results, and team involvement. This metadata, in turn, provides actionable insights on areas for further enablement.
While Net Promoter Score (NPS) is a barometer for customer satisfaction, it’s more of an output metric. To indeed influence NPS, one needs to target the underlying operational metrics. Identifying and coaching behaviors such as empathy, understanding customer needs, problem-solving, and product knowledge can substantially uplift customer experience. Furthermore, AI tools enable the identification of these behaviors across interactions, facilitating targeted coaching.
Despite advancements, success doesn’t solely rest on sophisticated metrics like Average Handle Time, First Call Resolution Rate, or NPS. The real game-changer is the ability to segment data based on specific topics, dispositions, or concerns. This deeper dive into the data helps us understand how these factors influence output metrics, offering a roadmap for more tailored coaching.
Ultimately, while AI provides invaluable insights, the human touch remains irreplaceable. Team leads play a pivotal role in influencing agent behavior and driving change. The real power of AI isn’t just the insights it provides but the ways it empowers human leaders to act on them, fostering a seamless blend of technology and human connection.
Emerging Trends and Technologies in AI-Driven Customer Service
The technological evolution in recent years has significantly impacted our daily lives. Solutions like ChatGPT have illuminated the vast possibilities of AI. Other tools, like Midjourney and Dall-E, symbolize the growing potential of Generative AI, anticipated to revolutionize various facets of our existence. As we move forward, customers increasingly expect instantaneous answers. While the human touch remains crucial in many interactions, there’s a rising demand for quick, automated solutions. Consequently, chat solutions incorporating generative capabilities might bridge this gap, offering customers human-like interactions and immediate responses.
However, businesses must identify their unique selling points as they employ these tools. Some might stand out for their cost-effective solutions or technological prowess. Others, particularly those with a relational focus, aim to distinguish themselves by understanding and catering to their customers. AI’s role in such businesses would be more supportive, bolstering specialists and designers rather than replacing them. As self-service becomes more common, companies should always maintain the availability of human support.
Generative AI, specifically, is advancing rapidly. With features that enhance quality assurance and generate automated summaries, businesses can increasingly move towards self-service modules. Imagine a system where every customer interaction, even those with chatbots or IVRs, is evaluated. Feedback loops could be established, refining these self-service points. As more straightforward questions are automated, one intriguing question arises: how will it affect the training and sustenance of contact centers, especially given their historically high turnover rates?
But even in the face of growing automation, many companies find strength in their internal teams. These in-house teams often have a deeper connection to the brand and mission, creating a sense of ownership and pride in the company’s successes and failures. Companies that keep most of their operations insourced tend to prioritize specialist knowledge and loyalty. They value employees who engage customers in meaningful conversations, emphasizing interpersonal skills over rote memorization. As technology simplifies many tasks, the human element in customer interaction remains irreplaceable.
Incorporating AI assistance in real-time can be transformative for agents. Tools like AgentGPT from Level AI can evaluate past conversations to suggest successful resolution steps, equipping agents with a dynamic knowledge base. Such advancements aren’t limited to in-house teams. They can also be employed by third-party vendors, or BPOs, to maintain the consistency and quality of customer interactions.
In summary, integrating AI in customer service doesn’t just benefit businesses—it offers a window into customer feedback. Tools that evaluate customer interactions can provide product teams with invaluable insights, driving product development and enhancing user experience. However, in this delicate balance of technology and trust, companies must strive to optimize their operations while preserving the sanctity of the customer relationship, ensuring that every interaction, be it human or AI-driven, remains rooted in respect, understanding, and a commitment to excellence.
Keep reading
View all
